Our previous studies demonstrated that menadione is cytotoxic to rat platelets. In an attempt to assess the relative contributions of enzymatic redox cycling versus arylation in menadione-induced cytotoxicity, we have studied three quinones with different mechanisms of action: 2,3-dimethoxy-1,4-naphthoquinone (DMNQ; pure redox cycler), menadione (both redox cycler and arylator), and 1,4-benzoquinone (BQ; pure arylator). BQ was more toxic to rat platelets than menadione, while DMNQ did not cause LDH leakage at all. Cellular uptake kinetics revealed that DMNQ concentration taken up by the cells was equivalent to that decreased in incubation medium. On the other hand, the concentrations of BQ and menadione taken into the cells were significantly lower than the decreases in concentrations seen in the incubation medium. This suggests indirectly that BQ and menadione may have undergone arylation, binding to glutathione (GSH) or protein thiols. The difference in arylation capacity between BQ and menadione was well correlated with their relative cytotoxicity (LDH leakage) observed in platelets. All three quinones caused a rapid, extensive depletion of intracellular GSH in platelets. Treatments with BQ and menadione did not result in formation of oxidized glutathione (GSSG), whereas DMNQ showed a time-dependent increase in GSSG. Altogether, these results suggest that enzymatic redox cycling does not play a critical role in quinone-induced cytotoxicity in rat platelets, while arylation is likely to be quinone's primary mechanism of action.