PT - JOURNAL ARTICLE AU - William J Harrison AU - Peter J Bex TI - Visual crowding is a combination of an increase of positional uncertainty, source confusion, and featural averaging AID - 10.1101/088898 DP - 2016 Jan 01 TA - bioRxiv PG - 088898 4099 - http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/11/21/088898.short 4100 - http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/11/21/088898.full AB - Although we perceive a richly detailed visual world, our ability to identify 1 individual objects is severely limited in clutter, particularly in peripheral vision. Models of such crowding have generally been driven by the phenomenological misidentifications of crowded targets: using stimuli that do not easily combine to form a unique symbol (e.g. letters or objects), observers typically confuse the source of objects and report either the target or a distractor, but when continuous features are used (e.g. orientated gratings or line positions) observers report a feature somewhere between the target and distractor. To reconcile these accounts, we develop a hybrid method of adjustment that allows detailed analysis of these multiple error categories. Observers reported the orientation of a target, under several distractor conditions, by adjusting an identical foveal target. We apply new modelling to quantify whether perceptual reports show evidence of positional uncertainty, source confusion, and featural averaging on a trial-by-trial basis. Our results show that observers make a large proportion of source-confusion errors. However, our study also reveals the distribution of perceptual reports that underlie performance in this crowding task more generally: aggregate errors cannot be neatly labelled because they are heterogeneous and their structure depends on target-distractor distance.